Jamie Carragher and Thomas Frank disagree over who was to blame for costly Tottenham mistake

Tottenham put on a lousy performance in the East Midlands and paid the price.

Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has disagreed with Thomas Frank over who is to blame for the first goal Tottenham conceded against Nottingham Forest on Sunday. Spurs lost 3-0 at the City Ground and simply failed to turn up, putting in a performance that left Frank with plenty of frustration on the back of a positive week or so that saw Spurs pick up seven points from nine in all competitions.

Vicario and Gray were involved in Tottenham's first concessionplaceholder image
Vicario and Gray were involved in Tottenham's first concession | Getty Images

Forest took the lead after a calamity at the back from Tottenham, with the Midlands side going to to score two more goals from distance.

For the first goal, Vicario played a pass to Archie Gray, who was immediately put under pressure, and the youngster’s failure to play the ball with his first touch meant he was immediately dispossessed. Although, there is already plenty of discussion over whether the fault lies with Gray for not releasing the ball quickly or whether Vicario should have avoided putting his young teammate in trouble with the risky pass.

For Sky Sports pundit Carragher, the blame lies with Vicario. “It's not just a keeper playing out,” said the Liverpool legend. “It's a keeper on his weak foot. Typical Vicario, he is always blaming someone else.

“Every time I see a goal go in, he throws his arms at someone else. He seems to do it a lot, and he did it again today. We can talk about young Archie Gray in midfield, but I'm putting this on the goalkeeper. Archie Gray could do a lot better, of course, he could, but what the lad does initially is he is trying to help someone who doesn't actually need help.

“The goalkeeper doesn't actually need any help because the ball should go out wide to his player. I don't know what the problem is. There is no real pressure on it.”

Frank blames Gray

Although he was forgiving of Gray’s error, Spurs boss Frank pointed to the versatile midfielder as the source of the issue. Asked if Vicario could be blamed, Frank said: “No. I think you see that every week in the Premier League, from every team, all over the world. So, there's no problem with that."

Asked about Gray’s error he added: “I've said before, mistakes happen, stuff like that. Of course I'll be irritated about it because you like to avoid it, but he will learn. I think it was a classic thing, you see, week in, week out. It's ball-playing to one of the two sitters, bounce it out, first touch, not take a touch. He will learn from that. I'm pretty sure he'll use one touch next time."

Frank himself is now coming under pressure as Spurs continue to struggle to step into the European spots, but the Dane has warned that anyone in charge of the club at this point will need time to succeed. He said: "I can't see why not. I think it's pretty evident that if no-one gets the time, no-one can turn this around. This is not a quick fix."

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice