Rio Ferdinand explains what Moises Caicedo does better than Declan Rice

Rio Ferdinand has been discussing the differences between the Premier League’s best two holding midfielders.

Rio Ferdinand has been discussing the debate between two of the best holding midfielders in the Premier League - and perhaps even the world. Chelsea’s Moises Caicedo and Declan Rice are now the established kings of the holding role in the Premier League, though Martin Zubimendi is also entering that conversation early in his time in North London.

There isn't much between the twoplaceholder image
There isn't much between the two | Arsenal FC via Getty Images

Caicedo had a slow start to his Chelsea career, having to live up to a huge price tag, but he is now playing at N’Golo Kante levels of yesteryear, and is one of the most consistent players across any position in the league.

Rice also arrived at Arsenal for a huge fee, and he has been a vital player for Arsenal since arriving, and it must be said, he looks to be offering even more now that he has a player like Zubimendi alongside him who can operate in a similar role to what Rice was playing.

Some fans have been debating whether Caicedo or RIce has the upper-hand in the comparison between the two, but as Ferdinand points out, they each have different strengths to their game.

On his podcast, Ferdinand said: “It's swings and roundabouts, they have a lot of similarities about their game. I think Declan, if you let him off his leash, he'll give you more going forward. But Caicedo, defensively, he smells danger quicker and better.

"I don't think there's much between them, so I'd be happy with either. When they were both on the market, I was screaming for Manchester United to go and buy them because I saw the value in Caicedo.

"I thought Caicedo would've been magnificent for Manchester United given time, while Declan would've been a ridiculous signing. It's splitting hairs between the two, I'll be honest. It depends what position you're going to play them in, if you're playing them as a holding midfielder, I'd probably say Caicedo. As a number eight, then I'd say Declan.

"You let Declan go, [then] he scores more goals than Caicedo all day long and he creates all day long. They'd be a nightmare to play against together."

The stat comparison

Both players have made seven appearances this season, with Caicedo starting seven times, while Rice has started six and come off the bench another time. Rice has one goal and two assists, while Caicedo has three goals and is yet to provide an assist.

Caicedo has won Man of the Match three times based on WhoScored rating, while Rice has once. The Chelsea man has an average rating of 7.48 compared to Rice’s still impressive 7.14.

The two have a very similar pass success percentage, with Rice on 91.5 and Caicedo on 91.3. Rice has won slightly more aerial duels, winning 0.6 compared to Caicedo’s 0.4 per game. Caicedo is managing an average of 1.1 shots per game compared to Rice’s 0.9 so far.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice