'Knives Out 3' review: A fresh, clever take on faith and the whodunit

placeholder image
Netflix

The third entry in the Knives Out saga, Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery, is both the darkest and most daring instalment yet.

Shifting from the flamboyant excess of Glass Onion to a small-town parish simmering with secrets, Johnson crafts a whodunit that feels deeply rooted in genre traditions while also pulling the genre into new emotional terrain.

The story follows young priest Jud Duplenticy (Josh O’Connor), who is assigned to assist the fiery Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin).

When an impossible murder shakes the parish, police chief Geraldine Scott (Mila Kunis) joins forces with Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) to unravel a case that seems to defy all logic.

It’s a premise that sets up classic murder mystery intrigue, yet rather than simply stacking twist upon twist, Johnson reshapes the very rhythm of the genre.

There are still plenty of shocks, but the surprises often come from unexpected character revelations and emotional beats, not just the mechanics of the crime.

The result is a narrative that is constantly shifting under your feet and a move that keeps a very tropey genre unexpectedly fresh.

Meet your new cast of suspects!placeholder image
Meet your new cast of suspects! | Netflix

Here, Craig fully inhabits the role of Detective Blanc with wit and gravitas, and this freedom to explore empathy, intelligence, and humour.

As much as I loved him in Casino Royale, it’s hard not to think he’s more at home as Blanc than he ever was as Bond.

Opposite him, Josh O’Connor delivers perhaps his finest performance yet, turning Jud into a character both haunted by his past yet determined to do the right thing.

Director Rian Johnson beside Daniel Craig at Wake Up Dead Man's premiere at the BFI London Film Festival.placeholder image
Director Rian Johnson beside Daniel Craig at Wake Up Dead Man's premiere at the BFI London Film Festival. | Getty Images for BFI

I would go as far as to argue that he, unlike anyone else in this franchise, manages to steal the leading man role from Craig.

While the rest of the characters here lack the punch of Knives Out’s original dysfunctional family, Johnson ensures that most of the characters feel three-dimensional, a step up from the somewhat broad caricatures of Glass Onion.

Plus, it was nice seeing Thomas Haden Church on the big screen again.

Just like the first two instalments, this film demands more than just attention from its audience.placeholder image
Just like the first two instalments, this film demands more than just attention from its audience. | Netflix

By far, this is the darkest and most emotional film of the trilogy, but it’s also the most important.

The moral weight of faith, hypocrisy, and guilt hangs over every scene, transforming what could have been a simple puzzle into something hauntingly human.

Johnson seems less concerned with tricking us and more with making us feel the consequences of deceit and devotion, while trusting the audience enough to keep up, read between the lines, and find meaning beyond the murder.

This is on full display, particularly with Jefferson Wicks, Cy (Daryl McCormack), Lee (Andrew Scott), and Martha (Glenn Close).

Is Benoit & Jud the new Holmes & Watson?placeholder image
Is Benoit & Jud the new Holmes & Watson? | Netflix

Just as striking as the film’s mystery is its visuals.

Johnson and his team capture sunlight with a realism rarely seen on screen, and the darkness of the small-town setting heightens both the serenity and menace of the film’s story.

His affection for the mystery genre, combined with his instinct for reinvention, makes Wake Up Dead Man essential viewing.

If the trilogy has explored suburban secrets, perhaps the next step is a chaotic urban sprawl where Benoit Blanc can test his wits against the noise of modern life.

Daniel Craig and Rian Johnson have both expressed interest in a Knives Out 4.placeholder image
Daniel Craig and Rian Johnson have both expressed interest in a Knives Out 4. | Netflix

For now, though, Wake Up Dead Man stands tall as a reminder that even in familiar genres, there are still new ways to surprise, to move, and to entertain.

Netflix would be wise to let him continue building this universe, for fans, the thrill lies not just in solving the crime, but in seeing how Johnson continues to reshape the rules.

If only there wer an app to discuss Jeremy Renner’s role in this film...

Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery is available to watch in cinemas for a limited time from 26th November before hitting Netflix on 12th December.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice