Political opinion: Reducing numbers at Notting Hill Carnival a "physical impossibility" says former Senior Mayoral Advisor

On 9 July Carnival organisers confirmed the event will go ahead after securing £1m in funding for stewarding. The money, provided by City Hall along with Kensington & Chelsea and Westminster councils, allowed organisers to meet Metropolitan Police safety guidance on crowd density – though only weeks before the event is due to go ahead.

Lee Jasper, former Senior Advisor to Mayor Ken Livingstone took no surprise to the tight turn around for this flow of cash, he said: “Councils play Russian Roulette with carnival every year.”

“They fundamentally undermined the ability of Notting Hill Carnival Limited to be able to put in a strategic operational plan, because they’ve left it to the last minute.”

With two weeks to go before Carnival on 12 August, Leader of the City Hall Conservatives, Susan Hall, has released a review called ‘On the Brink: Notting Hill Carnival’, which outlines her recommendations on Carnival’s future including relocating to Hyde Park, ticketing the event, commercial sponsorship and giving organising power to City Hall.

Lee Jasper, Former Senior Advisor to Mayor Ken Livingstoneplaceholder image
Lee Jasper, Former Senior Advisor to Mayor Ken Livingstone

Hall cites as her major concern as public safety, stating: “We must find another way – no other event would be allowed to continue like this.”

On the discourse that precedes Carnival each year, Jasper said: “Throughout the summer, there’s masses of positivity about carnival, but that never sees the light of day because it’s overshadowed by these public order problems and that is a convenient manufacture to shape public opinion about carnival as a very dangerous event, and that accords with the sort of racial stereotypes that people have in their minds about black culture and black and black people.”

These public safety concerns around crowd density are not new and have been an issue for Jasper since the early 2000s. Jasper’s relationship to carnival dates back decades and to his former position as Chair of the Mangrove Association - a service formed to aid the local Notting Hill community in response to the wrongful trial of the Mangrove 9, where nine black activists were arrested after police raided the Mangrove restaurant on suspicion of drug offences.

The 2004 Notting Hill Carnival Strategic Review was chaired by Lee Jasper and commissioned by the Greater London Authority in collaboration with the London School of Economics. The report assessed all elements of Notting Hill Carnival whilst consulting with Carnival organisers. Jasper said: “It still stands the test of time, and all of the issues that are identified are still relevant.”

“One of the key features was that I wanted to delineate who was responsible for public safety at carnival.” The 2004 review group produced a ‘Carnival Public Safety Matrix’, which determined that with public investment came public accountability, and therefore Kensington & Chelsea, City of Westminster and the MET police should bear the responsibility for public safety. Held predominantly within the Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea, this year the council supported crowd management and safety by providing a necessary grant of £200,000. However, the Deputy Leader of the Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council, Kim Taylor-Smith, said: “Following Government funding proposals, this Council is now facing significant funding pressures over the next three years, with budget gaps of around £80 million. So we have to be really clear that this is additional funding for this year only.”

Two options have been floated regarding long-term solutions to carnival: expansion or ticketing. The ticketing of carnival has surfaced as an option for years however the feasibility of reducing numbers proves very difficult, and what Jasper called “a physical impossibility”. He suggested that if the event were ticketed people would still take to the streets for Carnival and greater safety concerns would emerge. Jasper suggested the solution is to “cope with the ever-growing number of people each year.”

The exponential growth of carnival was raised by the review in 2004, concluding that within reason the event’s attendance would grow by 3-5% every year. However, the physical space of the route has remained the same since the 1980s when the festival saw under a million attendees.

The resistance to expansion belongs to the council according to Jasper. He stated that the Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea and City of Westminster’s resistance to expanding Carnival are to prevent it from spilling over into wealthy areas. Jasper acknowledged the politics that has long impacted carnival. He said: “The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea never wanted carnival to grow to this sort of scale on their patch.”

“A very appropriate analogy is George Floyd because Carnival can’t breathe.”

The efforts of organisers have been exhausted when trying to voice legitimate safety concerns and the necessary fixes like expansions, Jasper said. He describes how organisers have had to adopt a “trench war mentality”. Implying that resilience can wear thin for organisers, where ultimately protecting carnival and making sure it goes ahead become the main the priority.

Jasper said: “They haven’t got the strategic headroom or bandwidth to lift their head up to see the skyline, which is “What is the future of carnival?” “How are we going to ensure this fabulous cultural event?” Jasper’s ideas for building an all round sustainable future for carnival were simple. Financially, he offered a solution of giving Notting Hill Carnival the ability to license alcohol sales - which are currently distributed by the relevant council, who see those profits.

And on the issue of crowd density he posed a slightly harsher reality on what could bring about change. Jasper said: “It will take a legal challenge, and I may well mount one. It’ll take a legal challenge or a tragedy.”

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice