Professor Paul Crawford: Prisons hurt minds
Professor Paul Crawford at The Institute of Mental Health explores whether confinement in prison is responsible for a deepening mental health crisis.
During the pandemic many of us experienced the uncomfortable world of prolonged confinement. Indeed, it was as if we were all on a NASA analogue mission, being tested for a trip to Mars. It brought great psychological distress. Even now, the mental health impacts of being stuck between four walls during Covid-19 are still being felt.
In Cabin Fever: Surviving the Coronavirus Pandemic, my son and I put a spotlight on the mental health impacts of lockdowns based on what is known about the psychological impacts of confinement in prison.
Cabin fever from prolonged confinement is real: increased irritability and violence, depression, anxiety, suicidal behaviour. In the penal context, this folk syndrome is sometimes referred to as going stir-crazy (derived from the use of stir to mean ‘prison’). This condition is not to be taken lightly and has implications for our social futures, once people are released from prisons back into communities.


As we wrote: “Confinement in prisons around the world is diverse but most share a similar restriction in freedom and space for those living in them. Prisoners or inmates are locked up in different kinds of small cells or holding areas. Some share cells, with overcrowding a feature of prison life worldwide. Others may be subject to spending prolonged periods of time on their own in solitary confinement. Cells may be visible from other cells or hidden from view. They may be empty or with limited furnishing or sanitation. Prisoners may be allowed some personal possessions or none at all.”
We know that prison life can be repetitive and both monotony and extreme boredom feature strongly. This penal milieu is damaging. The highly restricted private space is emotionally oppressive. Prisons which tend to be overcrowded provoke high stress levels. In short, prisons that are designed with highly limited spaces for prisoners, or long hours in confined cells, cultivate trauma, a turn to mental decline, violence and suicide.
So, are prisons worth it? They may well satisfy society’s need to punish people for their crimes yet in return the minds of prisoners released back into our communities may be so damaged that any notion of rehabilitation is lost to the wind. Worse still, prisons as currently established may be adding to the growing mental health crisis.
In my latest novel, The Wonders of Doctor Bent, Dr Bent, the reforming medical director of a high-security psychiatric hospital, Foston Hall, attempts to create a less prison-like environment, commissioning a raised ground or tump, so that patients can see over the high fencing. His actions make us wonder more widely as to whether the design and set up of prisons needs revisiting, needs to mitigate for the extremes of confinement.


Prisoners cooped up for much of the day in their cells is sure to produce damaged minds that further burdens society. After all, the removal of freedom does not necessitate mentally damaging confinements.
Isn’t it time for a more humane and less counterproductive approach? Isn’t it time to build prisons where confinement is lessened and meaningful activity increased?
Paul Crawford’s The Wonders of Doctor Bent is available at Amazon, Waterstones, WHSmith, Foyles, Cranthorpe Millner, and all good bookshops.